×
〈 〉

20 High School Yearbook Awards That Would Cause Outrage Today


20 High School Yearbook Awards That Would Cause Outrage Today


The Page Everybody Turned To First

Senior superlatives began appearing in American yearbooks in the early 1900s, and by midcentury, most schools were handing out some version of the same awards. Plenty amounted to popularity contests, with the entire student body voting on which classmates looked best or deserved a less flattering label. Schools have spent decades dropping the harsher categories, and recent controversies have ended with apologies and recalled yearbooks. Some awards that once appeared every spring would barely make it past the yearbook adviser today. Here are 20 old-school yearbook superlatives that schools would think twice about printing today.  

179495167282d404dd2aba1e403a0e3b483caa528be420a324.jpgRifki Kurniawan on Unsplash

Advertisement

1. Best Figure

Nearly every yearbook in the 1970s carried a category for best figure, printed alongside best legs and best build. A school was holding a vote on which sixteen-year-old had the best body and then putting the result in a permanent record. The modern replacement is most athletic, an award for something the winner did rather than something he was born with.

1794947087b64b5d62e7566db985fa0d9f98a143458f57f7c7.jpgGarin Chadwick on Unsplash

Advertisement

2. Most Likely to Bomb the U.S.

An Arizona charter school apologized and reprinted its yearbook in 2018 after this appeared beside the photo of a student with a Muslim first name. Nobody had voted on it. The K–8 school let students write their own superlatives, and an eighth grader submitted this one. The yearbook adviser missed it, and the line made it all the way into the printed books.

1794947165d703e2bcb38fb433c3bb1d1146c79239e9ca4ca1.jpgKaramat Ali on Unsplash

Advertisement

3. Best Legs

Best Legs used to be a yearbook award of its own, separate from “Best Figure,” and schools were still printing body-based superlatives into the late 1980s. Modern yearbook guides recommend dropping these categories altogether, since asking teenagers to rank their classmates' bodies can make an already self-conscious age even harder.

179495122647eb5b3b42096bd8c2f5bee3ade49c8d6fcb3484.jpgLucrezia Carnelos on Unsplash

Advertisement

4. Nicest Car

Students at a New York high school criticized awards like “Nicest Car” and “Most Adorable” in their own school newspaper, calling them superficial and demeaning to those who didn't win. “Nicest Car” is especially hard to defend, since the award has less to do with the student than with how much their parents can afford to spend.

17949512570071d7c86d4db86915345b4df1e94b36d0c4389a.jpgKarsten Winegeart on Unsplash

Advertisement

5. Best Rear View

A Boston exam school’s 1989 yearbook included awards for both “Best Body” and “Best Rear View,” chosen by the student yearbook staff. The school’s newspaper has since looked back on those categories as something best left in the past, though it has also argued for restoring some of the harmless awards dropped along the way. 

1794951293b335c3368887465b90c5d314ef1d74896db30f18.jpgAlexander Schimmeck on Unsplash

Advertisement

6. Most Likely to Get COVID Twice

A California high school recalled its entire yearbook run in 2021 over this award and one other. Staff had tried covering the labels with stickers before handing the books out, and that failed once students worked out the stickers peeled off. Several students were listed underneath, including one who had been bullied all year.

17949513395ace9101e8ccbb039d781b1cec41fce18fbc186d.jpgengin akyurt on Unsplash

Advertisement

7. Biggest Appetite

Biggest appetite turned up in 1970s yearbooks with the same ceremony as best dressed. It sat a page or two from best figure, which tells you how the two were meant to be read together.

17949514627a9ae207bea919425fa9584f12c2bfbf58282fd8.jpgFotos on Unsplash

Advertisement

8. Most Attractive

Most Attractive was the catchall award, with other categories picking apart specific features of a student’s appearance. As schools shifted toward recognizing achievements and personality, this was one of the first awards to fall out of favor.

1794951533e95177a0a33e21f7233eeefd6d565adf762af528.jpegАнна Вилкова on Pexels

Advertisement

9. Most Likely to Contract a Disease

A St. Louis school district cited this award as the sort of superlative that could get a yearbook into trouble, according to a student press group’s report from roughly two decades ago. Awards that single out students for unflattering traits have long been a source of complaints, and advisers now have to consider whether an offended family might take legal action. 

1794951576e8d0db001aeb67f36cd28c041213437659354ebc.jpgAndrew Measham on Unsplash

Advertisement

10. Best Build

Who else was getting ranked? Boys had their own body-based superlatives, though those tend to get overlooked in discussions about old yearbook awards. “Best Build” asked students to judge their male classmates’ physiques, then printed the winner’s name for everyone to see. 

179495161386f4c101ec673da292eeb92b28b1e1787bf42657.jpgjohan du plessis on Unsplash

Advertisement

 

11. Class Airhead

“Class Airhead” hasn't disappeared so much as gotten a new name. Modern yearbook guides suggest replacing it with “Most Likely to Ask the Question Everyone Was Thinking,” keeping the joke without calling anyone stupid. That approach tends to go over better than cutting the funny categories entirely, especially when students feel their yearbook is losing its sense of humor.

17949516566c4c17bb70f56bbf0b9bbcc9a5025ceddc610793.jpegAndrea Piacquadio on Pexels

Advertisement

12. Most Likely to Be Canceled

This was the other half of the California yearbook recall. The school had covered the offending awards with stickers bearing harmless titles like “Best Dancer” and “Movie Star,” but students could peel them off to see what had originally been printed. 

1794951779fd7df3184d5496be890f1d31d7fca6274d8d1f62.jpegMART PRODUCTION on Pexels

Advertisement

13. Easiest Girl

Biggest Flirt sounds harmless enough by modern yearbook standards, but at some schools it replaced the far uglier Easiest Girl, a title that had appeared in superlative lists for years. The student newspaper that documented the change considered the original name an obvious problem, but argued that renaming insulting categories wasn't enough. Its position was that negative superlatives should disappear altogether.

1794952093715d7ebb56d3f5c23032c16552d6cdfbae12a71f.jpgKaty Ward on Unsplash

Advertisement

14. Separate Winners by Race

Some Southern schools printed two sets of superlative winners on the same page, one for white students and one for Black students. A Mississippi district kept a version of the practice until 2010, assigning class offices by race and splitting the homecoming court the same way. The board reversed the thirty-year-old policy in an emergency session the week it reached the national news.

1794952169e5dc96289beebe20cb9ac2a4f8e35c89a8aa2242.jpegmickael ange konan on Pexels

Advertisement

15. Prettiest Smile

Prettiest smile sounds harmless enough and sat in the same block as all the rest. A third of the page was effectively a referendum on faces, and no single award on it looked unreasonable by itself. Schools that cut the body categories usually took this one in the same pass.

1794952196e8844d42954c16b4077d432d474aad53e97b1ba2.jpgVicky Hladynets on Unsplash

Advertisement

16. Most Likely to Marry Rich

Most likely to marry rich still circulates on the sample lists, and advisers have been flagging it for years. One of them put the problem plainly, asking whether the award is a compliment or a way of calling a classmate a gold digger in print. It survives mostly because it reads as a joke, and the lists keep reprinting it.

179495222543100411019829d83215a6a34f8492587216aedd.jpegFurkan Tumer on Pexels

Advertisement

17. Most Changed

Most Changed remains a staple of senior superlatives, usually with a freshman photo placed beside a senior photo to show the transformation. The award sounds innocent enough, but there's an awkward implication in asking classmates to vote on who looks most different. Winning can feel like a compliment until you realize everyone is comparing you to a version of yourself they'd apparently rather forget.

179495226253c06a238d118966e617fa91ec5397d17e0963b8.jpgmalte on Unsplash

Advertisement

18. Most Annoying Male

A special education teacher in Indiana handed an eleven-year-old boy with autism a trophy engraved most annoying male, presented at an awards luncheon in front of his classmates and the school principal. The district apologized to the family and disciplined the staff involved. 

1794952800d53df7ec8835e69705ddff5501c662cdce5694ef.jpegTima Miroshnichenko on Pexels

Advertisement

19. Most Popular

Most popular ran for decades and stated outright the premise the rest of the page left implied. Student papers have been calling the whole section a popularity contest for years, and this is the award that admits it. It has dropped off the modern lists while nearly every other classic category survived.

1794952364c0c3012a6ea18850a9ff905b0fa6604bf0109a59.jpegSound On on Pexels

Advertisement

20. Quietest

Quietest ran as its own category on midcentury Who's Who pages, printed alongside school spirit and class athletes. The award singles out a student for saying the least. Modern lists have dropped it, while class clown, its loud counterpart, is still on almost every one.

1794952381748b533ee44ad85a6b66e7eb38ebb695d391a7eb.jpgSasun Bughdaryan on Unsplash

Advertisement