Do You Like Them or Are You Delulu?
It’s easy to confuse a crush on someone with a crush on the version of them you’ve built in your head, especially when you don't have a lot to build off of. Your imagination can run wild when you don't know someone that well yet, and that means you'll often fantasize an ideal that doesn't actually exist. When you actually like them, though, your interest doesn't waver even as you learn more about them; instead, you only fall deeper. Here are 10 signs you’re more into the "idea" of them, and 10 that suggest you're genuinely crushing on them.
juan pablo rodriguez on Unsplash
1. You Prioritize Their Potential, Not Their Pattern
When you're only fantasizing about the "idea" of someone, you'll often give more weight to what they might become than who they are right now. Even when their behavior doesn’t match what you want, you find yourself explaining it away because you don’t want to let go of the version you’re hoping for. Over time, that creates a situation where you’re emotionally committed to a person who won't appear.
Karolina Grabowska www.kaboompics.com on Pexels
2. Your Interest Thrives on Uncertainty
You feel most energized when you can’t quite tell where you stand, because it's the unknown that keeps your mind busy. Once things are clear and stable, the excitement plummets, and you start searching for signs that something is missing. That usually means the suspense is providing the spark more than the person is.
3. You Have to Constantly Rely on a "Spark"
Big nights, flirty conversations, and special plans light you up, but ordinary time together doesn’t... actually feel as appealing. You might avoid casual hangouts because you’re worried the chemistry won’t feel as strong when nothing is happening. If you only enjoy the highs, it’s worth asking whether you’d actually like them normally.
Bonaventure Fernandez on Pexels
4. You Downplay Deal-Breakers Because You Want It to Work
When they do things that would normally make you take a step back, you treat them as exceptions rather than glaring red flags. Instead of adjusting your expectations, you keep making room for behavior that doesn’t really align with what you need, thinking that maybe you just need to give them the benefit of the doubt.
5. You Enjoy Talking About Them, But Not to Them
You can spend a lot of time discussing your crush with friends, replaying details, and trying to decode what’s going on. But when it comes to actually responding to them or spending time together, it somehow feels draining or strangely uninteresting. That might be a pretty telling sign that you're not genuinely into them.
Priscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦 on Unsplash
6. You're in It for the Chase
You love the rush of attention, the validation, or the feeling that you’re being pursued, and that means their character and compatibility can become secondary because you’re more focused on what their interest does for your confidence. When the biggest benefit is the emotional high, liking them can get mixed up with liking the feeling.
7. Being Into Them Makes You Overthink
Instead of feeling calm and connected, you feel like you’re constantly monitoring the dynamic. You reread texts, rethink your tone, and worry about saying the wrong thing because it feels like one misstep could change everything. That kind of ongoing anxiety often comes from uncertainty and idealization rather than real closeness.
8. You Treat Their Attention Like Something You Need to Earn
Do you often find yourself trying to prove you’re worthy of their time, as if their interest is a prize you have to win? If the goal is just winning them over, it’s easy to ignore the question of whether you even enjoy who they are.
9. You Avoid Scrutinizing Because It Might Pop the Fantasy
You don’t ask deeper questions because part of you doesn’t want the answers to complicate your feelings. If you learned something that didn’t match your hopes, you’d have to rethink the whole situation, and that feels uncomfortable. Avoiding clarity can keep the excitement alive, but it also keeps you from seeing the truth.
Karolina Grabowska www.kaboompics.com on Pexels
10. You Know Their Image Better Than Their Character
Sure, you can describe what makes them attractive, impressive, or desirable, but you’d struggle to explain what really matters to them. Their values, habits, and emotional maturity can stay vague because you haven’t spent time understanding them beyond the surface. If you’re drawn mainly to their image, you may be more into the idea of them than, well, them.
Not convinced and still think you're head over heels for your crush? Here's how to tell you actually like them for them:
1. You Let Their Actions Shape Your View of Them
You don't just pay attention to how charming they can be in the right moment, but you focus on how they show up. When they follow through, take responsibility, or treat you with care, you notice it and trust it, because it’s consistent. When they don’t, you also lock that information in instead of brushing it aside.
2. You Enjoy Them in Normal, Everyday Moments
It’s not just exciting when there’s a flirty vibe or a perfect setting. You can have a simple conversation or do something routine together and still feel genuinely glad you spent that time with them. If you enjoy being with them in normal, everyday moments, that usually means you’re connecting with the person, not the thrill.
3. You Stay Curious About How They Think
You ask questions that go beyond small talk because you actually want to understand their perspective. Even when you disagree, you’re interested rather than defensive, because you’re not trying to force sameness. Real liking often looks like ongoing curiosity paired with respect.
4. You Respect Their Limits
If they move slowly, need space, or set up specific boundaries, you don’t treat it like rejection or a challenge to overcome. You can communicate your needs while still honoring theirs, which keeps the connection healthier and more honest. That kind of maturity is hard to sustain if you’re only chasing a fantasy.
5. You Feel Comfortable Being Yourself Around Them
You don’t feel pressure to constantly impress, entertain, or stay perfectly composed. Your sense of connection doesn’t depend on performing, because you trust they can handle the real version of you. When you can be yourself and still feel liked, it’s a strong sign the interest is genuine.
Priscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦 on Unsplash
6. You Notice Their Flaws Without Turning Them Into a Crisis
You’re aware they’re not perfect, and you don’t need them to be. Instead of ignoring their weaknesses or magnifying them into proof that it won’t work, you evaluate them realistically. That balance shows you’re engaging with a full person rather than an ideal.
7. You Want to Contribute to Their Life, Not Redesign It
You care about their well-being and growth, but you don’t approach them like someone you need to fix. Supporting them looks like encouragement, honesty, and showing up, not trying to control their choices or rush their progress. When you like someone for real, you make room for who they are while still keeping your own standards.
8. You Show Up Consistently Without Needing a Constant Spark
Even during busy weeks, you still make an effort because you want to, not because you feel anxious about losing them. You don’t rely on drama or intensity to stay interested, and you don’t disappear just because things feel normal. Consistency is often what genuine liking looks like in practice.
Jonathan J. Castellon on Unsplash
9. You Care About Their Character in Everyday Situations
How they handle stress, conflict, and other people matters to you, because you’re paying attention to the full picture. You notice whether they’re respectful when no one is watching and whether they can admit when they’re wrong. That kind of attention usually means you’re thinking realistically about compatibility.
10. You Can Be Honest Without Forcing a Label
You’re able to communicate clearly and show real interest without playing games or creating confusion. At the same time, you don’t feel rushed to define everything immediately just to soothe anxiety. When you can be sincere, steady, and grounded, you’re probably actually liking them.
